The Blanketing Debate

Will a Blanket Make Your Horse Happier This Winter?

TL;DR: Blanketing isn't a one-size-fits-all decision. Some horses stay warm with a natural winter coat, while others need extra support depending on their body condition, work level, weather, and environment. This guide helps you understand when to blanket, when not to, and the key factors that contribute to winter comfort.

Every year, someone asks me if they should I blanket their horse, or if I think their horse’s natural winter coat is enough.

If you scroll any horse group online, you’ll see strong opinions on both sides. But the real answer depends on your horse. 

There’s really no universal rule. It depends on your horse, their situation, and your local weather.

At Happy Horses, we encourage you to look at the whole picture.

When Blanketing Can Be the Right Choice

Blanketing can help if your horse:

1. Is Clipped
   A clipped horse has lost part or all of their natural insulation. Without that coat, they’re more vulnerable to wind and cold.
2. Has Trouble Maintaining Weight
   Some horses maintain weight easily, while others (often referred to as hard keepers) burn calories quickly and need more feed to stay at a healthy condition. These horses may use extra energy trying to stay warm in winter, so a blanket can help them hold that warmth without losing weight.
3. Lives in Wet or Windy Conditions
   Rain, sleet and wind can flatten the coat and make it harder for your horse to stay warm. A blanket helps prevent heat loss in these conditions. A dry, layered blanket can make a big difference.
4. Needs to Stay Cleaner for Riding or Showing
   If your horse is worked throughout the winter, blanketing helps keep the coat length more manageable and reduces the time needed for grooming.

When Your Horse May Not Need a Blanket

Your horse may do perfectly well without a blanket if:

1. They Grow a Full, Healthy Winter Coat
   If your horse grows a thick, clean winter coat and it stays dry, their natural insulation usually provides enough warmth on its own.
2. They Have Access to Shelter
   Trees, run-ins, and windbreaks help horses regulate temperature naturally.
3. They Maintain Weight Easily
   Moderate and easy keepers often stay warm simply through normal metabolic processes.
4. The Climate Is Cold but Dry
   Dry cold is far easier for horses to tolerate than damp, windy cold.
5. They Have Free-Choice Forage
   Eating hay produces internal heat and is one of the most natural ways horses stay warm.

What to Consider When Deciding

• Coat condition (clipped or natural)
• Age, weight, and general health
• Turnout environment
• Wind, moisture, and temperature changes
• Your horse’s natural “run hot” or “run cold” tendency
• Frequency of riding and grooming needs

Different horses in the same barn may need different blanketing plans, and that’s completely normal.

How to Tell If Your Horse Is Too Cold

• Shivering
• Tight muscles
• Cold ears and cold flank/armpit area
• Tucked tail
• Standing hunched or unwilling to move freely

How to Tell If Your Horse Is Too Warm

• Sweating under the blanket
• Damp coat when you lift the blanket
• Agitated or restless behavior
• Choosing to stand in open, windy areas instead of shelter

If you choose to blanket, check daily and adjust for weather changes. Overheating under blankets is more common than most people realize.

Nutrition Plays a Major Role

Staying warm is not just about blankets. A horse’s ability to hold heat begins with balanced nutrition. 

If minerals, protein, and amino acids are out of balance, you may notice:

• Dull coat
• Hard time maintaining weight
• Slower recovery from work
• Decreased energy
• Difficulty staying warm

Balanced nutrition helps the body use feed efficiently and maintain warmth more comfortably. The Happy Horses Maintenance Blend provides balanced minerals and essential amino acids to support a healthy coat, steady energy, and overall condition. 

Many owners notice improvements such as shinier coats, more stable weight, and better winter comfort once nutrition is balanced, often in as little as one month.

So… Blanket or Don’t Blanket?

If you need help deciding, send us a message with your horse’s:

• Age
• Body condition score
• Work level
• Living setup (pasture, pen, stall, shelter access) 

We’ll help you figure out whether your horse is likely best suited to:
No blanket, a light sheet, a medium, or a heavier weight.

Happy Horses.  Happy Humans.

Top of Form

If you want hands-on guidance with your horse, Taylor hosts clinics throughout the year. The focus is on body control, timing, and building feel with your horse. Clinics are hands-on, practical, and kept small enough for each rider to receive individual support.  

Upcoming clinic information can be found here: Happy Horses